Project Management and the Short Order Cook

by | Updated February 19, 2018 | Business & Leadership, Dynamics 365 for Finance and Operations, Dynamics AX, Dynamics NAV

In most professions, there are variations to the art and science of them. There are a variety of specialists in the medical professions, in teaching, in the culinary arts, etc.

And in managing and leadership, we have had many a discussion about the differences between Supervisors, Managers and Leaders, and what they do differently, and where you need what type of skills and personality.

I have long been curious about these concepts when it comes to Project Management. There are Project Coordinators and then there is the Project Manager (PM), Senior Project Manager, Principal Project Manager differentiations. For many, this likely depended on years of experience and budget size or size of project teams we have dealt with. Those data points or ranges determined how the position would be categorized.

But what about the actual use and need for a PM on a project?

You don’t hire a short order cook to be your party planner or the other way around! You would have to rely on sheer luck that the person also has the talent, experience, and enjoys doing something so unlike their chosen profession.

Now how does that relate to hiring the right project manager for the job? I think the questions to ask when trying to find the right one should be centered on what you will have that individual do.

  • Do you need someone who primarily sets up meetings, organizes project activities and events?
  • Do you need someone who is really good with spreadsheets and will track deliverables and test cases and other spreadsheet-able tasks?
  • Do you need someone who will be a controller for the project actual and budget track the spending of time and $ and report against it?
  • Do you need someone who creates variations of detailed project plans to satisfy different stakeholders expectations as to what a project plan looks like, and works on keeping them all current?


  • Do you need someone who works with the project stakeholders across all work streams and brings the big picture together?
  • Do you need someone who can identify risks and assess likelihood and impact and develop mitigation plans accordingly?
  • Do you need someone who develops and offers trade-offs, identifies what activities can progress when others are behind or have to yield to new priorities?
  • Do you need someone who is a great change agent and will partner with leaders in project-impacted departments on preparing them for the future?
  • Do you need someone who is trusted and respected by leadership to be clued in on planned scope changes early enough to develop impact models?

I am sure I could keep adding to the list for a while but I think these examples are likely sufficient to illustrate the variables. If you need someone who is good at the top four and hire someone who excels at the bottom four listed activities neither one of you will be happy, and the same is true the other way around.

Make a seasoned strategic thinking project leader with good people skills a “spreadsheet jockey,” tasked with creating plan variations upon request and you will have frustration on both sides. Likewise, if you put an outstanding project coordinator or controller in the role of a project leader you will have someone out of their element who does not enjoy the less tangible work, the influencing, and you may end up with stakeholders and partners who might be frustrated with more tactical responses.

Ultimately the generic term of project manager takes reputation hit after hit, not because we as PMs are not able to do a good job, but because the “match-making” often falls short of putting the right kind of PM into the right kind of role.

Which role do you need?

So, if you need a project coordinator/controller who will track the project successfully to completion, who will create the reports that show where you are at, and assist with setting up meetings: hire exactly that skill set, talent and expectation, and everyone will be happy with the assignment and the eventual outcome.

And if in fact, you need a project leader who can work on the non-tangibles, on the people side, the change impact, the tradeoffs, anticipating what scope, risk or issue might be around the corner, the stakeholders, especially the reluctant ones then hire that skill set, talent, and expectation and there will be great satisfaction all around.

I do believe that this is true for the in-house PM search as much as for finding the right partner PM for a project. As for the large engagements where an in-house PM meets a partner PMs getting clarity around who falls into which category, and how much overlap do they have and how well do they complement each other will be crucial to the success of the project that put them both there. And yes, some projects are large enough where you will need both – and possibly more than one of each.

I am looking forward to thoughts and feedback from the community!

Related Posts


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Upcoming Events


01sep10:00 am10:30 amEnsuring Quality and Compliance for Batch Manufacturers in Life Sciences

01sep12:00 pm12:30 pmIs it Worth It to Move to the Cloud? A Look at Considerations for Current Agribusinesses Using Dynamics GP

01sep2:00 pm2:45 pmWhat’s New in Dynamics 365 Finance and Supply Chain

09sep11:00 am12:00 pmConfab Live with Stoneridge – Data Strategy and Reporting – Mining Decision Making Insights

15sep10:00 am11:00 amSolving the Biggest Challenges in Agribusiness Through Innovation and Technology

22sep12:00 am12:30 pmSimplifying Payroll and HR Management with ADP Workforce Now

22sep10:00 am10:30 amStreamlining Batch Manufacturing with Technology

22sep2:00 pm2:30 pmProcess Automation for Microsoft Dynamics D365 for Business Central, Finance and Operations and GP

23sep11:00 am12:00 pmConfab LIVE with Stoneridge - Riding the Wave 2 Release – Key Features Coming to Dynamics 365 this October

27sep(sep 27)9:00 am15oct(oct 15)11:00 amDynamics 365 Finance & Supply Chain Development Training - Online Workshop

29sep10:00 am11:00 amTop Five Reasons Why NOW is the Right Time to Move from Salesforce to Dynamics 365 Customer Engagement

29sep12:00 pm12:45 pmUnderstanding Job Costing and Tax Management in Business Central

29sep2:00 pm3:00 pmDigitalizing Horticulture & Agriculture - How to Sell Plants Online and Simplify Business Management

30sep12:00 pm4:00 pmSecurity and Permissions Training for D365 Business Central or Dynamics NAV


27sep(sep 27)9:00 am15oct(oct 15)11:00 amDynamics 365 Finance & Supply Chain Development Training - Online Workshop

06oct10:00 am10:30 amPreview of D365 Business Central Fall Release Features and Functionality

06oct12:00 pm12:30 pmInsider's Guide to New Features Available in the Fall Release of D365 Finance and Supply Chain

07oct11:00 am12:00 pmConfab LIVE with Stoneridge - Dataverse and Dynamics in Review – Let’s Get Technical

21oct11:00 am12:00 pmConfab LIVE with Stoneridge - Dataverse and Dynamics in Review – Let’s Get Functional

26oct(oct 26)9:00 am28(oct 28)5:00 pmStoneridge Connect Leadership and Community Conference

About Stoneridge
Stoneridge Software is a unique Microsoft Gold Partner, with emphasis on partner. With specialties in Microsoft Dynamics 365, Microsoft Dynamics AX, Microsoft Dynamics NAV, Microsoft Dynamics GP and Microsoft Dynamics CRM, we focus on attracting the most knowledgeable experts in the field to our team, and prioritize delivering stellar solutions with maximum impact for your business. At Stoneridge, we are deeply committed to your results. Each engagement is met with a dedicated team, ready to provide thorough, tailored, and expert service. Based in Minnesota, we intentionally “step into your shoes,” wherever you are. We focus on what you care about, and develop trusting, long-term relationships with our clients.

Subscribe To Our Blog

Sign up to get periodic updates on the latest posts.

Thank you for subscribing!