Constant Consumption vs. Constant Scrap in AX 2012 and How it Affects Cost

by | Updated August 15, 2016 | Dynamics AX, Financials, Manufacturing, Set Up

When using formulas in AX 2012 there are two main options for accounting for a fixed usage of material: constant consumption or constant scrap. We’ll explore both options and how it affects cost in this post. The reasons for that fixed usage could be that there is start-up for the process or a known amount of waste, due to not being able to get everything out of a mixing vessel for example. Deciding which option would be preferred for your organization could depend on the preference of accounting and where you want see that cost in a standard cost environment.

Using Constant Scrap

On the formula in the setup tab there is a field for constant scrap. In this field you would enter an amount of material that gets consumed in the process, generally as waste, that is fixed no matter the batch size.

Constant Scrap in AX 2012

 

When the fixed quantity is placed in the constant scrap field and the calculation functionality is used to generate the item price, the value of the constant scrap is included in the price field. In the example below, the cost on the bottom is calculated without any constant consumption. The price on the top is calculated with a constant scrap on one of the lines.

Item Price in Dynamics AX

The advantage of using the constant scrap field is that it is less work for the person setting up the formula and all of your cost price is in one field.

 

Using ‘Consumption is Constant’ Line

Another way to handle fixed consumption would be to change the ‘consumption is’ field from variable to constant. This is also done in the setup tab of the formula lines. Now instead of putting your quantity in the constant scrap field, the quantity would go in the quantity field. Again, with the ‘consumption is’ field set to constant, the value in the quantity field is fixed no matter the batch size.

Consumption is Constant

 

When the fixed quantity is placed on a separate line with the ‘consumption is’ field set to constant, and the calculation functionality is used to generate the item price, the value of the fixed quantity is included in the price charges field. In the example below, the cost on the bottom is calculated without any constant consumption. The price in the middle is calculated with a constant scrap on one of the lines. And the price on the top is calculated with the fixed quantity on a separate line. In this case the price charges amount is divided by the price quantity, so the per part affect is $0.08 just like it was when using the constant scrap field.

adam_final price 4

 

The advantages of creating a separate line with the consumption is set to constant is that those fixed quantity costs are broken out separately. This would allow a business to focus on items with a large price charges value as areas of process improvement to try and reduce that quantity. The disadvantage is that it is more work for the person setting up the formula.

Constant Consumption vs. Constant Scrap Summary

In the end, the method chosen is largely dependent on the needs and the preference of the business. Both methods result in the same per unit cost, but the amount of work required and the ability to have those costs broken out or not are the deciding factors.

Related Posts

  • Depending upon your setup in Dynamics AX 2012, you may find that discounts entered on a purchase line do not seem to be included in the inventory cost transactions, even…

  • **Updated 11/20/2013** There are quite a few important keyboard shortcuts that can really save some time when entering data and moving around in AX 2012.  One in particular - hitting…

  • The much anticipated release of AX 2012 R2 has been announced. Here are the new features that have my attention. I'll be sure to post some detail, as I explore…

2 Comments

  1. zg

    hi, Is there a report that gives me the separation of the calculation of material and tell me how much was scrap?

  2. Brandon Carmichael

    Hello ZG:

    I am not aware of report that gives the separation of the calculation of material along with the scrap. That being said, you could always create you own report that meets your needs.

    Thanks,
    Brandon

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Upcoming Events

october

07oct12:00 pm1:00 pmThe Three Paths to Business Central from Dynamics GP

08oct11:00 am12:00 pmConfab with Stoneridge - Livestream - The Vision and Strategy of Microsoft Business Systems

14oct10:00 am10:30 amThe Modern Manufacturer - Managing Complex Cost Modeling

14oct12:00 pm12:30 pmGenerating Custom Inspection or Process Forms

19octAll Day22Stoneridge Connect Fall 2020

22oct11:00 am12:00 pmConfab with Stoneridge - Livestream - Stoneridge Connect Recap

28oct10:00 am10:30 amThe Modern Manufacturer - Engineering Change Management: Introduction of NEW Functionality for Manufacturers Using Dynamics 365

november

18nov10:00 am10:30 amThe Modern Manufacturer - Tears and Trauma of MRP

About Stoneridge
Stoneridge Software is a unique Microsoft Gold Partner, with emphasis on partner. With specialties in Microsoft Dynamics 365, Microsoft Dynamics AX, Microsoft Dynamics NAV, Microsoft Dynamics GP and Microsoft Dynamics CRM, we focus on attracting the most knowledgeable experts in the field to our team, and prioritize delivering stellar solutions with maximum impact for your business. At Stoneridge, we are deeply committed to your results. Each engagement is met with a dedicated team, ready to provide thorough, tailored, and expert service. Based in Minnesota, we intentionally “step into your shoes,” wherever you are. We focus on what you care about, and develop trusting, long-term relationships with our clients.

Subscribe To Our Blog

Sign up to get periodic updates on the latest posts.

Thank you for subscribing!

X